The hearing room on the fourth floor of the Veridania Ministry of Social Welfare smelled of ammonia and old paper. Adrian Kastner sat in a molded plastic chair that had been designed by someone who had never experienced back pain, its lumbar support a cruel joke pressing into the precise spot where his fifth lumbar vertebra had decided, some twelve years ago, to begin its slow betrayal of everything he was.
The administrative judge, a man named Drexler whose face had long ago settled into the permanent expression of someone smelling milk that might be off, shuffled papers on his desk. He did not look at Adrian. In the eighty-seven minutes since the hearing had begun, he had looked at Adrian exactly twice—once to swear him in, and once to ask, with evident skepticism, whether the claimant understood that the allowance board's resources were finite.
"Mr. Kastner," Drexler said now, addressing his question to a medical exhibit propped on an easel beside his desk, "you claim total disability due to what you describe as intractable pain resulting from degenerative facet joint disease. Is that correct?"
Adrian tried to straighten in his chair. The motion sent a familiar bolt of electricity down his left leg, and he abandoned it halfway through. "Yes. That's correct."
"And yet the vocational expert has identified three occupations in the national economy that you could theoretically perform. Surveillance system monitor. Call center operator. Ticket sorter." Drexler pronounced each occupation as though it were a gift he was personally bestowing. "These are sedentary positions, Mr. Kastner. No lifting required."
Adrian's hands, resting on his thighs, curled into loose fists. He thought of them as they had been fifteen years ago, before the pain had become his constant companion—steady enough to hold a brush for fourteen hours straight, delicate enough to lay a glaze so thin it was barely a whisper of color. Those hands had restored a Raphael Madonna that the Uffizi had given up for lost. Those hands had been praised by men who knew what hands were worth.
"I cannot sit for more than twenty minutes at a time," Adrian said. His voice came out flat, deadened by the effort of not screaming. "I cannot stand for more than ten. I sleep in three-hour increments when the medication works, and not at all when it doesn't. The vocational expert has never met me. The vocational expert does not know that on bad days, I cannot lift a brush to a canvas. On bad days, I cannot lift a spoon to my mouth."
Drexler made a note. Adrian watched the pen move across the paper and felt the familiar sinking sensation of a man watching his life being reduced to a notation in a file that no one would ever read with care.
"Your medical records indicate that you continue to paint," Drexler said. "The board's consulting physician noted that artistic activity of this nature suggests a residual functional capacity inconsistent with your claimed limitations."
The words hung in the air. Adrian felt something crack open inside him, a small fissure in the wall he had built to contain the rage that had been accumulating for years. He thought of the paintings he still managed to produce—small things, studies mostly, executed in twenty-minute bursts between episodes of agony. He thought of the way his dealer in the old town sold them for a fraction of what his work had once commanded. He thought of the Raphael Madonna, which now hung in a climate-controlled gallery in Geneva, attributed to "Studio of Raphael" because the restoration had been so complete that the cognoscenti could no longer tell where the master ended and the restorer began.
"Your Honor," Adrian said, and the honorific caught in his throat like a bone, "I paint because if I did not paint, I would have ceased to exist as a person long ago. I paint in defiance of the pain, not in the absence of it. The fact that I occasionally manage to produce something does not mean I am capable of working a call center shift. It means I am capable of suffering through something that matters to me, at great cost, for brief periods of time."
Drexler's pen paused. For a moment, Adrian thought he had reached the man, had found some small aperture in the armor of bureaucratic indifference through which a sliver of human recognition might pass.
Then Drexler said: "The board's consulting physician also noted that your pain complaints are, and I quote, 'disproportionate to the objective clinical findings.'"
The fissure inside Adrian widened. He had heard this before, from doctors who looked at his MRI and saw only mild to moderate degeneration, who could not understand why a spine that looked relatively unremarkable on film could produce agony that felt like being slowly lowered into boiling oil. He had learned, over the years, that there were two kinds of pain in the world: the kind that showed up on scans, and the kind that didn't. The first kind received sympathy and opioids. The second kind received skeptical glances and recommendations for cognitive behavioral therapy.
"My objective clinical findings," Adrian said quietly, "do not include a machine that can measure what I feel."
Drexler closed the file. The sound was very loud in the small room.
"The board will issue its decision in writing within thirty days. This hearing is adjourned."
Adrian remained in the plastic chair for a long moment after Drexler departed. The vocational expert, a woman whose name he had already forgotten, gathered her papers and left without meeting his eyes. The court reporter packed up her stenography machine with the practiced efficiency of someone who had transcribed a thousand such hearings and would transcribe a thousand more.
Outside, the November rain was falling in sheets. Veridania's capital, Ostengrad, looked like a city that had been sketched in charcoal and then abandoned before the artist could finish the details. Adrian walked—slowly, carefully, with the gait of a man fifteen years older than his forty-two years—to the bus stop. Each step sent a calibrated message of protest from his spine to his brain, a telegram delivered in the code of nerve impulses that translated, inevitably, to the same three words: this is wrong.
His apartment was in the Artisans' Quarter, a once-thriving enclave of studios and galleries that had been slowly succumbing to gentrification for the past decade. The building's elevator had been broken since August. Adrian climbed the four flights of stairs one at a time, pausing on each landing to breathe through the pain, and by the time he reached his door, the sweat on his forehead was cold and his hands were trembling.
The studio was exactly as he had left it. A half-finished landscape on the easel, commissioned by a dentist in the suburbs who wanted something soothing for his waiting room. A palette with dried paint in colors Adrian had mixed three days ago, when he had still believed, foolishly, that the hearing might go differently. A stack of medical bills on the table by the window, held down by a coffee mug that said "World's Greatest Dad"—a gift from his ex-wife, purchased during the brief period when they had still been able to laugh about the fact that they had no children.
Adrian sat down heavily on the stool in front of his easel. The landscape stared back at him, bland and inoffensive, a painting that asked nothing of its creator except basic competence. He had been painting things like this for five years now, ever since his body had made it impossible to do the restoration work that had once been his calling. Dentists' offices, hotel lobbies, corporate conference rooms—his work now inhabited the anonymous spaces of the world, seen by thousands and noticed by none.
He thought about the hearing. About Drexler's face, which had been a mask of bureaucratic skepticism worn so long it had become the man's actual face. About the consulting physician who had never examined him but had somehow determined that his pain was disproportionate. About the vocational expert who had suggested, with apparent seriousness, that a man who could not sit for more than twenty minutes might find fulfillment as a call center operator.
The rage that had been building for years finally crested. Adrian picked up the palette knife from his worktable and drove it through the center of the landscape. The canvas tore with a sound like a gasp. He struck again, and again, until the dentist's soothing vista was a ruin of shredded linen and gouged pigment, and then he dropped the knife and sat there, breathing hard, his spine screaming at him for the sudden violence of his movements.
In the silence that followed, his phone rang.
The number was blocked. Adrian almost didn't answer—he had been dodging calls from the collections department at Ostengrad General Hospital for the better part of six months—but something made him pick up. Some intuition, perhaps, or some desperate hope that the call might bring news that would change everything.
"Adrian Kastner?" The voice was male, cultivated, with the faint accent of the northern provinces. "My name is Lothar Voss. I believe you and I have a mutual acquaintance. A gentleman by the name of Gregor, who used to handle your work in the old days?"
Adrian's breath caught. Gregor had been his dealer during the restoration years, before the pain had forced him out of that world. Gregor had also been, as Adrian had discovered far too late, a man with extensive connections to the less legitimate corners of the art trade. They had parted ways acrimoniously, and Adrian had not spoken to him in nearly a decade.
"I'm not interested in anything Gregor is selling," Adrian said. "Goodbye."
"Wait." The voice remained calm, unhurried. "I'm not calling on Gregor's behalf. I'm calling on my own. I have a proposition for you, Mr. Kastner. A commission, of sorts. One that would pay quite well—certainly well enough to address your current financial difficulties—and that would make use of your particular talents."
Adrian should have hung up. Every instinct he possessed told him that this call was dangerous, that Lothar Voss was dangerous, that the world Gregor inhabited was one he had been lucky to escape with his life relatively intact.
Instead, he said: "What kind of commission?"
"There is a painting," Voss said. "A Caravaggio. 'The Penitent Saint.' Lost for three centuries, believed destroyed. I have reason to believe it exists, in a private collection, and I have a client who is very eager to acquire it. The problem, Mr. Kastner, is that the current owner is unwilling to sell. And so my client requires an alternative."
Adrian's hand tightened on the phone. He understood, with perfect clarity, what was being asked of him. He also understood something else: that the man on the other end of the line knew exactly who he was, knew about the Raphael restoration, knew about the hands that had once been steady enough to replicate a master's brushwork so perfectly that even experts could not tell the difference.
"I don't do that kind of work," Adrian said. But his voice lacked conviction, and he knew it.
"I think you'll find that circumstances can change one's definition of what kind of work one does," Voss said. "Meet me tomorrow evening. There's a cafe in the old town, the Café Valois. Nine o'clock. We'll discuss the details. And Mr. Kastner?"
"Yes?"
"Do bring your portfolio. I'm told it's extraordinary."
The line went dead. Adrian sat in the ruins of his studio, the phone still pressed to his ear, listening to the silence. Outside, the rain continued to fall on Ostengrad, washing the streets of a city that had forgotten him, that had declared his suffering insufficient, that had looked at his broken body and seen only a man who should try harder.
He thought about the Caravaggio. About the hands of a master, dead four hundred years, reaching across centuries to touch his own. About what it would mean to channel those hands, to become a vessel for a genius that was not his own but that he could replicate, perfectly, down to the last brushstroke.
He thought about Drexler's face, the closed file, the vocational expert's averted eyes.
He thought about the landscape he had just destroyed, and about all the other landscapes waiting to be painted for dentists and hotel managers and corporate vice presidents who would hang them in conference rooms and never look at them twice.
And then, very slowly, he stood up, walked to his worktable, and began to clean his brushes.
Outside, the city slouched toward evening. Somewhere in the Artisans' Quarter, a church bell tolled seven times. In his studio, Adrian Kastner opened a fresh canvas, and began, for the first time in years, to paint something that mattered.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!