The spiral notebook with the sunflower cover sat on Elias Cormier's kitchen table until three in the morning, its pages illuminated by the weak glow of a brass desk lamp that had belonged to his father. Outside, the rain had stopped, and the silence of St. Jude after a storm was the kind of silence that amplified every sound — the drip of water from the eaves, the distant bark of a dog, the creak of the old house settling into its bones. Cormier read Tasha Rieux's second diary slowly, as if each word were a stone he was turning over in his hand.
Her handwriting was round and girlish, at odds with the sharpness of her observations. She had been a careful diarist, recording not just events but patterns. The first mention of the inventory discrepancies appeared on June 12th: "Found a purchase order for twelve Movado watches that never made it to the display case. Alvin says it was a shipping error, but the PO was signed as received. His signature. Something smells." By July 8th, her entries had grown more urgent: "Traced the missing merchandise to an online store called Bayou Luxury Goods. The shipping address is a warehouse on Old Mill Road. That's three miles from here. Someone is stealing from Gallatin's and selling it out the back door."
The final entry, dated July 31st, three days before her death, was only four lines: "Alvin knows I know. He cornered me in the break room today and said if I valued my job, I would stop looking into things that didn't concern me. I'm going to Mrs. St. Cloud on Monday. This has gone on long enough."
Cormier closed the notebook and pressed his fingers against his eyes until he saw stars. The timeline was damning. Tasha Rieux had discovered a theft ring operating inside Gallatin's Department Store, she had confronted the operations manager, and she had been killed before she could report what she knew. The state's case against Harold Vance was built on the assumption that a workplace dispute over a clearance rack had escalated into murder. But the clearance rack had been a pretext. The real dispute was between Tasha Rieux and Alvin Prejean, and the real stakes were not three feet of floor space but thousands of dollars in stolen merchandise and the reputation of a family-owned business that was already teetering on the edge of financial ruin.
The problem, Cormier knew, was proving it. He had a dead girl's diary and the testimony of a frightened accounting clerk. He had a fingerprint that should not have existed on the murder weapon. He had a defendant whose pathological habits made him simultaneously the most obvious suspect and the least plausible one. What he did not have was a direct connection between Alvin Prejean and the box-cutter, or between Prejean and the thumbprint that the state had hung its entire case upon.
He dressed at dawn in the same charcoal suit, now rumpled from two days of wear, and drove to the parish courthouse before the television trucks had resumed their vigil. The security guard at the metal detector recognized him and waved him through without a word. In the empty courtroom, the morning light fell through the tall windows in long, dusty columns, and the rows of wooden benches seemed to hold the ghosts of all the verdicts that had been rendered there.
Cormier sat at the defense table and spread the contents of his satchel before him: the journal, the forensic reports, the employee roster, the subpoenaed inventory records that had arrived late the previous evening from Gallatin's corporate office. The inventory records were dense columns of numbers and codes, but even a cursory glance revealed the pattern Tasha had identified — purchase orders marked as received, shipping manifests that showed smaller quantities than the orders, and a trail of missing high-value items that stretched back at least twenty-six months. The total value of the unaccounted merchandise exceeded one hundred and forty thousand dollars.
At nine o'clock, the courtroom began to fill. The journalists filed in, their laptops balanced on their knees. The civil rights observers took their seats in the front row. Loretta Rieux entered with her son, her face still composed but her eyes red-rimmed from a night of weeping. Harold Vance was led in by two deputies, his orange jumpsuit replaced by a gray suit that Cormier had arranged from a secondhand shop on Bayou Road. Vance walked to his seat with the same rigid posture, the same unblinking calm, but there was something different in his bearing this morning — a tension in his shoulders, as if the weight of the trial were finally pressing down on him.
Judge Devereaux gaveled the court to order, and the third day of testimony began. The state called its next witness: Detective Ray Landry, the lead investigator. Landry walked to the stand with the deliberate heaviness of a man who had testified in a hundred trials and had learned to treat the witness box as a form of theater. Under Wilde's direct examination, he described the crime scene with clinical precision, walking the jury through the position of Tasha Rieux's body, the location of the box-cutter, the blood spatter patterns on the stockroom floor. He described interviewing Harold Vance, noting that the defendant had shown "no visible emotion" when informed of the death. He presented the security log, the timecard data, the fingerprint report. By the time Wilde finished, the picture was complete: Harold Vance, a man of cold and meticulous habits, had killed Tasha Rieux in a moment of controlled violence and then walked back to the sales floor as if nothing had happened.
Cormier rose for cross-examination with the inventory records in his hand and the sunflower notebook tucked into his jacket pocket. He approached Landry slowly, letting the detective meet his eyes.
"Detective Landry, you testified that your investigation focused on Harold Vance from the very first day. Is that correct?"
"Yes, sir. The evidence pointed to him."
"And once the evidence pointed to him, did you investigate any other suspects?"
Landry shifted in his seat. "We followed the evidence where it led."
"That's not what I asked. I asked whether you investigated any other suspects. Did you, for example, investigate Alvin Prejean, the operations manager at Gallatin's?"
"We interviewed all the employees."
"But did you investigate Mr. Prejean as a potential suspect?"
"There was no evidence linking him to the crime."
Cormier held up the inventory records. "Detective, these records were provided to the defense by Gallatin's corporate office under subpoena. They show that over a two-year period, merchandise valued at more than one hundred and forty thousand dollars was ordered by the store, marked as received, but never appeared in the sales inventory. Are you aware of these discrepancies?"
Landry's expression flickered. "I was not."
"You were not. And yet Tasha Rieux had discovered these discrepancies. She had traced the missing merchandise to an online storefront operating out of a warehouse on Old Mill Road. She had confronted Alvin Prejean about it, and he had threatened her. She wrote in her diary, three days before her death, that she intended to report what she had found to the store's general manager. Did you know any of this, Detective?"
The courtroom was utterly silent. Wilde was on his feet, his face red, shouting an objection about hearsay and foundation. Judge Devereaux called both attorneys to the bench. For ten minutes, they argued in low voices, while the jury shifted in their seats and the gallery whispered. Finally, the judge ruled that Cormier could continue, but warned him to tread carefully.
Cormier turned back to Landry. "Let me ask you a simpler question, Detective. You testified that Harold Vance's thumbprint was found on the handle of the box-cutter. You testified that the print was deposited in the victim's blood. Did you investigate how that print might have gotten there, given that Mr. Vance habitually wears gloves whenever he touches any object in the store?"
"We assumed he removed his gloves."
"You assumed. And did you find any bloodied gloves in Mr. Vance's possession? In his locker? In his apartment?"
"No."
"Did you find any blood on his clothing?"
"No."
"Did you find any evidence that he washed his hands or his clothing after the murder?"
"No."
"So your theory is that a man who wears gloves every moment of his working life, a man who records every task he performs in a journal, a man who has not been seen without gloves in twenty-seven years, somehow removed his gloves, committed a brutal murder that would have drenched his hands and clothing in blood, and then... what, Detective? Walked back to the sales floor with clean hands and clean clothes, without anyone noticing, without recording a hand-washing in his journal, without leaving a single drop of blood anywhere except the thumbprint you found?"
Landry stared at him. His jaw worked silently. Finally, he said, "That is what the evidence suggests."
"No, Detective," Cormier said. "That is what your assumptions suggest. The evidence suggests something else entirely. No further questions."
The afternoon session brought a new witness: Alvin Prejean. Cormier had subpoenaed him after reviewing the inventory records, and Wilde had fought the subpoena with every tool at his disposal, but Judge Devereaux had ruled that the defense had a right to explore alternative theories of the crime. Prejean walked to the stand with the swagger of a man who had talked his way out of trouble before and expected to do so again. He was in his early forties, with a thick neck and small, watchful eyes that swept the courtroom like a security camera.
Cormier began gently. He established Prejean's position at Gallatin's, his responsibilities for inventory and shipping, his access to the stockroom and the loading dock. He asked about the morning of August 3rd, and Prejean stated that he had been at a vendor meeting in Baton Rouge, as scheduled, and had not returned to St. Jude until late afternoon.
"You have documentation of this meeting?" Cormier asked.
"Of course. My expense report, the mileage log, the meeting agenda."
"And yet, Mr. Prejean, Annette Doucet, a clerk in the accounting office, has testified that she saw you near the loading dock at approximately 7:50 on the morning of August 3rd. How do you explain that?"
Prejean's eyes flickered. "She's mistaken. I wasn't there."
"She's mistaken. I see." Cormier walked to the defense table and picked up a sheaf of papers. "Mr. Prejean, I'm holding the purchase orders and shipping manifests for Gallatin's Department Store for the past two years. These documents show a consistent pattern: high-value items ordered, marked as received, but never entered into the sales inventory. I'd like to direct your attention to a specific order from April of this year. Twelve Movado watches, total value eight thousand four hundred dollars. The purchase order bears your signature. The receiving manifest bears your signature. But the watches never appeared in the display case. Can you explain that?"
"Shipping errors happen."
"Twelve watches?"
"It's possible."
"And the twenty-seven other orders that followed the same pattern? The designer handbags, the gold jewelry, the premium kitchenware? All shipping errors?"
Prejean's face had begun to redden. "I don't know what you're implying."
"I'm not implying anything, Mr. Prejean. I'm asking you directly. Did you divert merchandise from Gallatin's Department Store to an online storefront called Bayou Luxury Goods?"
"No."
"Did you threaten Tasha Rieux when she discovered what you were doing?"
"No. I barely spoke to the girl."
"Were you in the stockroom on the morning of August 3rd, between the hours of 7:45 and 8:15 a.m.?"
"I already told you. I was in Baton Rouge."
Cormier paused. He reached into his satchel and withdrew a single sheet of paper — a phone record, obtained through subpoena from the cellular provider.
"This is your cell phone location data for August 3rd, Mr. Prejean. It shows your phone pinging off a tower in St. Jude at 7:52 a.m. and again at 8:14 a.m. The tower is located approximately one-quarter mile from Gallatin's Department Store. Would you like to revise your testimony?"
The blood drained from Prejean's face. He looked at Wilde, then at the judge, then at the jury. His hands, which had been resting on the rail of the witness box, began to tremble.
"I... I may have stopped by the store briefly. Before driving to Baton Rouge. I don't recall."
"You don't recall." Cormier let the words hang. "Mr. Prejean, I have one final question. Do you know how to lift a fingerprint?"
Wilde was on his feet, shouting. The gallery erupted. Judge Devereaux slammed her gavel with such force that the water pitcher on her desk rattled. She ordered the jury removed from the courtroom and turned a look of cold fury on Cormier.
"Counselor, you are walking a very fine line," she said. "You had better have a good reason for that question."
"I do, Your Honor," Cormier said. "The defense intends to show that the thumbprint on the murder weapon was deliberately placed there by someone who knew Harold Vance's routines and used them to frame an innocent man. We believe that person is Alvin Prejean."
The courtroom dissolved into chaos. Prejean was shouting denials. The journalists were typing furiously on their phones. Loretta Rieux had risen from her seat, her face a storm of confusion and dawning horror. And Harold Vance, the man at the center of it all, sat motionless at the defense table, his pale hands folded before him, his eyes fixed on a point in the middle distance where only he could see.
Judge Devereaux called a recess until the following morning. As the deputies led Prejean from the courtroom — not in handcuffs, not yet, but with a new wariness in their posture — Cormier gathered his papers and walked toward the exit. A hand caught his arm. It was Loretta Rieux.
"Is it true?" she asked. Her voice was raw. "What you said in there?"
"I believe it is, Mrs. Rieux. I believe your daughter was killed because she found out the truth. And I believe the man who killed her tried to make sure someone else paid for it."
She stared at him for a long moment, her eyes searching his face. Then she nodded, once, and released his arm. Cormier walked out of the courthouse into the gray afternoon, the weight of what he had set in motion pressing down on him like a stone.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!