The fourth day of testimony broke over St. Jude with a sky the color of a fresh bruise, and the air was thick with the promise of more rain. The crowd outside the courthouse had doubled since the previous afternoon, fed by news reports that had spread across the state like fire through dry grass. The phrase "planted fingerprint" was on every tongue, and the television anchors had already begun using the word "conspiracy" with the breathless excitement of people who sensed a story larger than they had understood.
Elias Cormier had not slept. He had spent the night in his office, the sunflower notebook open beside a growing pile of phone records, bank statements, and shipping logs that he had assembled with the help of a forensic accountant from Lake Charles who owed him a favor. The accountant, a wiry man named Patel who spoke in numbers the way poets spoke in metaphor, had traced the flow of money from Bayou Luxury Goods to a shell company registered in Alvin Prejean's name, and from there to a personal account at Cypress Parish Savings and Loan. The total deposits over two years matched the value of the missing merchandise to within a margin of three percent. The paper trail was complete. What remained was to make it speak.
The courtroom was so crowded that the bailiffs had been forced to open the side doors and allow spectators to stand along the walls. Every journalist in southern Louisiana seemed to have found a seat, and the sketch artists had their charcoal poised. In the front row, Loretta Rieux sat with her son, her hands clasped in her lap, her eyes fixed on the witness stand where Alvin Prejean had sat the day before. Across the aisle, Evelyn Vance had been joined by a small group of supporters — neighbors from Shreveport, a former colleague from the school where she had taught, and a thin, stooped man who Cormier recognized as Harold Vance's only living relative besides his sister.
Harold Vance himself was already seated at the defense table, his gray suit freshly pressed, his hands folded precisely before him. He did not look at the crowd or the jury or the journalists. He looked only at Cormier, and in his pale blue eyes there was something that had not been there before — not quite trust, but the fragile beginning of it.
Judge Devereaux took the bench at nine o'clock sharp, her silver hair gleaming under the fluorescent lights. She called the court to order with a single rap of her gavel and instructed the bailiff to bring in the jury. The twelve men and women filed in with expressions of nervous expectancy, the weight of what they had heard the previous day visible in the way they avoided looking at the defendant.
"Mr. Cormier," the judge said, "you indicated yesterday that you wished to recall a witness. Are you prepared to proceed?"
"I am, Your Honor. The defense recalls Alvin Prejean."
A murmur rippled through the gallery. Prejean was led in by a deputy, his swagger gone, replaced by a wary tension that made him look older than his forty-three years. He had spent the night consulting with an attorney — a high-priced criminal defense lawyer from New Orleans who had driven up before dawn and was now seated in the gallery, watching the proceedings with narrowed eyes. Prejean took the stand, and Judge Devereaux reminded him that he was still under oath.
Cormier approached the witness box slowly, carrying a single document in his hand. He did not speak immediately. He let the silence build, let the jury see Prejean's discomfort, let the weight of the moment settle over the courtroom like dust.
"Mr. Prejean, yesterday you testified that you were in Baton Rouge on the morning of August 3rd. You later revised that testimony to acknowledge that you may have stopped briefly at the store. Do you recall that?"
"Yes."
"And you testified that you had nothing to do with the missing merchandise from Gallatin's inventory. That the discrepancies were shipping errors. Do you recall that as well?"
"Yes."
"Mr. Prejean, I am now holding a certified statement from Cypress Parish Savings and Loan, documenting deposits to an account in your name over the past twenty-four months. The deposits total one hundred and thirty-seven thousand dollars. They correspond, within a narrow margin, to the value of the missing merchandise from Gallatin's Department Store. The source of these deposits was a shell company called Prejean Enterprises, which received its funds from Bayou Luxury Goods, the online storefront that sold the stolen items. Would you care to explain this to the jury?"
Prejean's face had gone gray. His lawyer in the gallery half-rose from his seat, but Prejean waved him down with a trembling hand. For a long moment, he said nothing at all. Then his shoulders slumped, and the defiance that had carried him through the previous day's testimony drained out of him like water from a cracked vessel.
"I made some mistakes," he said quietly.
"Speak up, Mr. Prejean," the judge instructed.
"I made some mistakes," Prejean repeated, louder. "The store was going under. I knew it. Cecily knew it. We were all going to lose our jobs. I thought I could make a little something on the side, just to protect myself. It was supposed to be temporary."
"And Tasha Rieux discovered what you were doing?"
"She was too smart for her own good." The words came out bitter, almost a sneer, and several jurors shifted in their seats. "She kept asking questions. She wouldn't let it go."
"So you threatened her?"
"I told her to mind her business. That's not a threat."
"And when she wouldn't mind her business, when she told you she was going to report your theft to Mrs. St. Cloud, what did you do, Mr. Prejean?"
The silence that followed was the longest Cormier had ever experienced in a courtroom. Prejean stared at his hands, which were gripping the rail of the witness box with white-knuckled force. His breath came in short, ragged gasps. The jury leaned forward. The journalists held their pens still.
"I didn't mean to kill her," Prejean whispered.
The courtroom erupted. Judge Devereaux banged her gavel repeatedly, shouting for order, but the noise from the gallery was a wave that took long seconds to subside. Loretta Rieux had buried her face in her son's shoulder. Evelyn Vance was weeping silently, her tears falling onto her clasped hands. Harold Vance sat motionless, his expression unchanged, but a single muscle in his jaw was twitching rhythmically.
When order was finally restored, Cormier spoke again, his voice steady and low. "Tell us what happened, Mr. Prejean. All of it."
Prejean took a shuddering breath. "I came in early that morning. I knew Tasha worked the opening shift. I thought I could talk to her one more time, make her understand. I found her in the stockroom. She was pulling merchandise for a display. I tried to reason with her, but she wouldn't listen. She said she had proof. She said she was going to make sure I went to jail."
"And then what?"
"There was a box-cutter on the shelf. I don't even remember picking it up. I just... I was so angry. I was so scared. And then she was on the floor, and there was blood everywhere, and I didn't know what to do."
"What did you do, Mr. Prejean?"
Prejean closed his eyes. "I remembered the glove. Vance's glove. He went through a pair every few hours, and he threw the used ones in the trash bin by the loading dock. I had seen him do it a hundred times. I took a glove from the bin. I used it to press his thumbprint onto the handle of the box-cutter. I had watched him enough to know he kept a journal, that he recorded everything, that he would have no alibi because his whole life was a schedule. I thought... I thought no one would question it."
The courtroom was silent. Even the journalists had stopped typing, their fingers frozen above their keyboards. The confession hung in the air like smoke, acrid and suffocating.
Cormier walked slowly back to the defense table. He picked up a plastic evidence bag containing a single white cotton glove, slightly soiled at the fingertips, and held it up for the jury to see.
"This glove," he said, "was recovered from the trash bin at the Gallatin's loading dock by a defense investigator three days ago. It has been tested by an independent forensic laboratory. The tests reveal two things: first, trace amounts of Harold Vance's skin cells on the interior, consistent with normal wear; and second, microscopic traces of Tasha Rieux's blood on the thumb and forefinger, deposited when the glove was used to press Vance's print onto the bloodied handle of the murder weapon. This glove, ladies and gentlemen, is the missing piece. It proves that the thumbprint was planted. It proves that Harold Vance did not kill Tasha Rieux. It proves that Alvin Prejean did."
Wilde was on his feet, his face a mask of professional fury, but his objection died in his throat. He looked at Prejean, at the jury, at the judge, and then he slowly sat back down. He knew — everyone in the courtroom knew — that the trial was over.
Prejean was taken into custody immediately, his sobs echoing off the high ceiling as the deputies led him away. The jury was dismissed to deliberate, but they returned in less than an hour with a verdict of not guilty on all charges. Harold Vance, the man who had been vilified in the press and condemned by public opinion, walked out of the St. Jude Parish Courthouse a free man.
But freedom, for Harold Vance, was a strange and complicated thing. He stood on the courthouse steps in the gray September light, blinking at the crowd of reporters and protesters and curious onlookers who had gathered to witness the end of the trial. His sister was at his side, her arm linked through his, but he seemed not to notice her. He seemed not to notice anyone.
Cormier approached him, pushing through the crush of bodies. "Mr. Vance, it's over. You can go home."
Vance turned his pale eyes toward the lawyer. For a long moment, he said nothing. Then, in a voice so quiet that Cormier had to lean in to hear, he spoke.
"Where is home, Mr. Cormier? I have spent twenty-seven years walking the same floors, touching the same fabrics, recording the same minutes. And now I am told that the world outside those walls is mine again. But I do not know that world. I do not know how to exist in it."
"You'll learn," Cormier said.
"Will I?" Vance looked down at his hands, which were bare. The white cotton gloves were gone. He had not put on a new pair since leaving the jail. "I am fifty-one years old. I have never been touched by another human being since my mother died. I have never eaten a meal I did not measure. I have never spent a minute I did not record. And now you tell me I am free. But freedom is chaos, Mr. Cormier. Freedom is a door that opens onto nothing."
Cormier had no answer for that. He watched as Evelyn Vance led her brother down the steps and into a waiting taxi, and he felt something hollow open in his chest — the recognition that he had saved a man from prison, but he could not save him from the prison of his own mind.
That evening, Cormier sat alone in his office, the sunflower notebook still open on his desk. The trial was over, but the case would not leave him. He thought about Tasha Rieux, a young woman who had believed in accountability and had paid for that belief with her life. He thought about Harold Vance, whose pathological discipline had made him both a suspect and a victim. And he thought about Alvin Prejean, a man whose greed had curdled into murder, and whose attempt to frame an innocent man had been undone by the very order he had sought to exploit.
The phone rang. Cormier let it ring. Outside, the rain began again, a soft pattering against the window, and the lights of St. Jude flickered in the darkness like a constellation of small, uncertain hopes. He closed the notebook and put it in his desk drawer, but he knew it would be there waiting for him in the morning, its pages full of a dead girl's voice, its cover bright with sunflowers that would never fade.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!